Dear FList, I could use some help.

[mapsedge]

Michelle and I cannot agree on a direction for the logo for Map's Edge Media. I would like to enlist your help in selecting a direction: which one of the following works better for you and why? Or, if you have an opinion for either, I'd like to know that, too. (Or, do you have a better idea you'd like to volunteer?)

Remember, this logo has to work on letterhead as well. Neither of the choices is probably the final, and they're in no particular order.

Choice 1:



Choice 2:

Comments

[iarraidh.livejournal.com]

Neither one yanks my chain, honestly.

Here's a thought to confuse the situation further...
Each logo takes into account a traditional map that you, I, and anybody over 40 recognizes.

But what graphic represents a 'map' to the up-and-coming consumers? Will they have as much trouble identifying with a fold or scroll hardcopy map as they do reading an analog clock?

Just 2 coppers...

[billthetailor.livejournal.com]

I was going to include an 8-Track tape in the logo, too. :)